Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Home    Challenges    Reviews    Features    Contests    Review Policy    Contact

Friday, November 12, 2010

Guest Post: Antony John (Author of FIVE FLAVORS OF DUMB)

Today, debut author Antony John visits the The Hiding Spot to discuss writing a female main character and the challenges involved... and the surprising lack of challenges too.
Be sure to check out my review of FIVE FLAVORS OF DUMB here. Find out more about Antony John here.

What’s it like to be a male author writing from a female perspective?

I was in a bookstore recently and someone asked me if it felt weird to be a guy writing from a girl’s perspective. Before I could answer, a bookseller who’d been listening in turned around and said: “He’s not deaf either, though, right?”

Actually, she could’ve kept going:

“He’s not eighteen.”

“He didn’t grow up in the States.”

“He didn’t attend a US high school.”

“His high school in England was single-sex.”

“He’s never played in a rock band.”

“He’s never managed a rock band.”

And on and on . . .

I’ve always thought that apart from entertainment, the main reason we read is to experience the world through someone else: to see things as they do, to face and overcome the hardships they encounter. This is also the main reason I write: for the privilege of empathizing fully with someone I will never be. The success of failure of a book often hinges on the author’s ability to pull this off.

In Piper’s case—she’s the narrator of FIVE FLAVORS OF DUMB, by the way—I had to do a lot of research: I mean, she doesn’t know anything about music, whereas I have a Ph.D. in music; she’s deaf, but I’m not. But most of my readers aren’t deaf either, and probably don’t know much about deafness. Whereas a LOT of my readers are female, which is why your question is so interesting. And embarrassing. See, it’s like this . . .

Confession time: In order to get fully inside Piper’s head, I had to get help every now and again.

In DUMB, Piper crushes on a boy. To be honest, I wasn’t completely convinced why she would like him all that much. So I asked my wife and sister-in-law: “What makes a boy attractive to a girl?” Now, as someone who has been happily married for a decade, I probably ought to have had some idea of this already, but I didn’t. And so both of them dutifully gave me a list of things that they would have found attractive in Piper’s situation. And I thought: “Huh. That makes sense. Cool.” And I included it. All of it.

Then there’s the moment where Piper makes out with someone-who-shall-remain-nameless. And I thought: “Huh. I’ve never kissed a guy. I wonder what that’s like.” So I asked. And again the answers were really illuminating, so I kept them in mind as I was writing the scene.

But you know what? As much as I had to ask for help for some parts of DUMB, I actually wrote 99 percent of it without asking for any advice at all. And the reason, I think, is that most of the challenges teens face are universal: they affect boys and girls equally. I completely understand Piper’s feelings of resentment toward her parents at the beginning of the book, because anyone would feel that way. I also know as well as Piper what it feels like to be an outsider at school, to crush on someone without them feeling the same way about me, to want to excel academically without having friends think I’m a geek/nerd/dork/loser (choose your noun). And, like Piper, I felt everything intensely as a teen. Seriously, I over-thought everything, and had enough hang-ups for entire class of students. Thankfully, I get to channel that into writing now, which is perfect.

So what was it like writing from a girl’s perspective? Fun, interesting, educational. And a lot like living high school all over again. Only this time, it was co-ed!


Find out more about FIVE FLAVORS OF DUMB and read my review here.


  1. I actually love that you've written from a female perspective. It's new to me (honestly I haven't read many books from male authors), that's for sure but I'd love to see how you tackle it once I get a chance to read DUMB.

  2. Thanks for this, Sara! The more I hear about Antony and FIVE FLAVORS OF DUMB the more I'm looking forward to reading it. I want to make a visit to my local bookstore soon!

  3. Hello Fellow Blogger! Wanted to show some love and say your blog is wonderful. I myself just started a new blog and could really use your support. Return the favor and become a follower?

  4. +JMJ+

    I think this is a great post! Most writers, I think, want to have narrators/central characters whom they can imagine being without having to ask so many questions. Totally understandable. But it's the exceptions who are most interesting!

    Aside from John, another who really comes to mind is Alexander McCall Smith, a Scottish writer who has written many books about a lady detective in Botswana.


Make sure you whisper, I'm hiding!